Back to blog

BeautifulSoup Alternatives for Web Scraping in 2024

Roberta Aukstikalnyte

2024-07-164 min read

Beautiful Soup is a Python library for parsing HTML and XML documents, making it an efficient tool for web scraping. This library is indeed a highly popular choice in the data extraction industry, and rightfully so. However, what you may now know is that there are alternative libraries which potentially are better for your specific use case.

In today’s article, we’ll compare six noteworthy alternatives to BeautifulSoup in 2024, focusing on what each offers and how they stack up against Beautiful Soup. Whether you are looking for speed, ease of use, or advanced features, understanding these alternatives will help you choose the right tool for your web scraping tasks. Let’s get started.

Beautiful Soup alternative tools comparison

To give our fair judgment in our Beautiful Soup vs. other Python libraries comparison (and one scraping API), we’ll evaluate each one based on the following metrics:

Ease of use: How user-friendly and intuitive the library is.
Performance: Speed and efficiency in web scraping large volumes of data.
Flexibility: Ability to handle different types of pages and complex scraping tasks.
Community and support: Availability of community support, documentation, and updates.
Additional features: Unique functionalities that set the library apart from others.

1. Oxylabs Custom Parser

Custom Parser is a feature of Oxylabs Web Scraper API tools that allows parsing scraped data according to your own instructions.

Pros:

Specific data: By setting your own parsing instructions, you can retrieve specific data needed.
No parser maintenance: Typically, parsers require a lot of maintenance (especially, if you’re scraping data from different websites.) Oxylabs takes care of their parser maintenance on their end, so customers don't have to worry.
Extensive documentation, video tutorials: Oxylabs Custom Parser has tutorials in multiple different formats (video, documentation) for customers to follow.

Cons:

Can’t be used on its own: To use Custom Parser, you need a subscription with Web Scraper API. In other words, you can’t use the Custom Parser tool on its own.
Paid: Custom Parser is the only paid tool on this list; however, it can be considered as one the most customer-friendly and easy-to-use out of the list.

You may claim a free trial for a Web Scraper API and test the Custom Parser feature for one week for free.

→Get free trial

“Custom Parser is a great addition to the Web Scraper API. By utilizing this extra feature, you get an exceptionally convenient scraping experience from start to finish.” - Aivaras Steponavicius, Senior Account Manager @ Oxylabs

2. lxml

lxml is a powerful library for parsing and processing XML and HTML documents. It is known for its speed and robust handling of complex structures, especially in web scraping. lxml supports XPath selectors for precise data extraction and can be used in combination with BeautifulSoup for better results.

Pros:

Speed: lxml is known for its high performance and speed, especially with large datasets.
XPath support: Strong support for XPath expressions, making it powerful for complex queries.

Cons:

Steeper learning curve: Can be more complex to learn and use compared to BeautifulSoup.
Error handling: Error messages can be less intuitive, making debugging more challenging.

"The performance of lxml with large XML and HTML documents is unparalleled. It's our go-to for high-volume web scraping tasks." - Web Developer, DataScrape Inc.

3. html5lib

html5lib is a Python library for parsing HTML that adheres strictly to the HTML5 specification, ensuring compatibility with all web documents, including poorly formatted HTML. It is often used in web scraping for its ability to create a parse tree similar to how modern browsers render pages, ensuring consistent and accurate data extraction.

Pros:

HTML5 compliance: Parses pages the same way as modern web browsers, ensuring high accuracy.
Ease of use: Simple and straightforward, similar to BeautifulSoup in terms of ease of use.

Cons:

Slower performance: Can be slower compared to other libraries like lxml.
Memory usage: Tends to use more memory, which might be a concern for large-scale web scraping.

"html5lib is great for projects where browser-like parsing is crucial. It handles malformed HTML beautifully." - Researcher, WebData Solutions.

4. PyQuery

PyQuery is a Python library that provides jQuery-like syntax for parsing and manipulating HTML, making it easier to navigate and extract data. It is used in web scraping to leverage jQuery's familiar and concise API for efficient document querying and manipulation.

We have a tutorial for parsing HTML data with PyQuery and you can check it out here.

Pros:

jQuery-like syntax: Intuitive and easy to use for those familiar with jQuery.
Flexibility: Combines the ease of BeautifulSoup with the power of jQuery selectors.

Cons:

Performance: Not as fast as lxml, especially for very large documents.
Limited documentation: Less extensive documentation compared to BeautifulSoup.

"Pyquery's syntax is incredibly intuitive. It made the transition from front-end development to web scraping seamless." - Front-end Developer, ScrapeIt.

5. Parsel

Parsel is a Python library used in web scraping for extracting data from HTML and XML files using CSS and XPath selectors. It is commonly used with Scrapy, providing robust and flexible web scraping tools for navigating and extracting data from pages.

Pros:

XPath and CSS selectors: Excellent support for both, making it versatile for different scraping needs.
Integration with Scrapy: Works well with Scrapy for more complex scraping projects.

Cons:

Learning curve: Might be challenging for beginners to grasp initially.
Standalone usage: Primarily designed to be used with Scrapy, standalone usage can be limited.

"Parsel's ability to work seamlessly with Scrapy has been a game-changer for our large-scale scraping projects." - Lead Engineer, DataMiner Corp.

6. Requests-HTML

Requests-HTML is a library that combines the capabilities of Requests and pyquery, allowing for easy HTML parsing, JavaScript rendering, and web scraping. It simplifies the process of fetching, rendering, and extracting data from web pages with an intuitive API.

Pros:

All-in-one solution: Combines HTTP requests, JavaScript rendering, and HTML parsing.
JavaScript support: Can render JavaScript, making it useful for dynamic websites.

Cons:

Complexity: More complex to set up and use than BeautifulSoup for simple tasks.
Performance: Rendering JavaScript can be slow and resource-intensive

"Requests-HTML has been invaluable for scraping JavaScript-heavy sites. It simplifies the entire process into one coherent library." - Data Scientist, WebScrapers Ltd.

The verdict

Best free: lxml

While the best choice depends on your specific needs, lxml is a great free BeautifulSoup alternative thanks to its high performance and powerful features.

Best overall: Custom Parser

Even though a paid tool, Oxylabs’ Custom Parser stands out for handling the majority of the websites, extensive documentation, and not having to take care of maintenance.

Wrapping up

While BeautifulSoup is a widely popular choice for parsing scraped data, Custom Parser is the best overall choice due to its ability to handle complex tasks with no maintenance and excellent support, despite requiring a subscription. For a free option, lxml offers high performance and powerful features, making it a strong alternative for large datasets.

About the author

Roberta Aukstikalnyte

Senior Content Manager

Roberta Aukstikalnyte is a Senior Content Manager at Oxylabs. Having worked various jobs in the tech industry, she especially enjoys finding ways to express complex ideas in simple ways through content. In her free time, Roberta unwinds by reading Ottessa Moshfegh's novels, going to boxing classes, and playing around with makeup.

Learn more about Roberta Aukstikalnyte

All information on Oxylabs Blog is provided on an "as is" basis and for informational purposes only. We make no representation and disclaim all liability with respect to your use of any information contained on Oxylabs Blog or any third-party websites that may be linked therein. Before engaging in scraping activities of any kind you should consult your legal advisors and carefully read the particular website's terms of service or receive a scraping license.