Dedicated IP vs Shared IP

The main difference between a dedicated and a shared IP address (IP is short for internet protocol) is that dedicated IPs are given exclusively to one user, whereas multiple users at the same time use shared IP addresses. 

When it comes to hiding your identity online, using proxies, be it reputable free proxies or paid proxy solutions, is a great way to stay anonymous and hide your real IP address.

However, once you start looking into proxy solutions, you’ll probably end up trying to choose between dedicated (a.k.a. private proxies) vs. shared proxies.

When it comes to the question “shared IP address vs. dedicated IP address”, the answer is that dedicated proxies are usually chosen more frequently rather than shared proxies. In this article, you'll find out why. 

But before we go into this, let’s take a minute to look a bit closer at the definitions of these two types of proxies.

Shared IP address vs. dedicated: main differences

The most significant difference between dedicated (private) vs. shared IP (internet protocol) addresses is that dedicated IP addresses are given exclusively to one user. Meanwhile, a shared IP address can be used by multiple users at the same time.

If you want to learn more about each IP address type, check out these posts:

• Shared Proxies

• What are Private Proxies?

Direct comparison of shared and dedicated IP addresses

Now, let’s compare both IP address types based on several different criteria. 

Risk of blocks. The main difference between a shared IP address and a dedicated IP address is how likely you’re to get blocked when scraping. When you’re using a dedicated IP address for web scraping, the chance of getting blocked is significantly smaller than with a shared one. 

Control. This point ties closely to the first one – being in control and having ownership of your IP addresses is what reduces the risk of getting blocked. After all, you’re in charge of what websites are being scraped with that specific IP, for how long, and in what manner; all that while knowing no one else is using that IP address at the moment. 

Speed. When it comes to web scraping, most users are looking for speed and unlimited bandwidth. Dedicated proxies are usually very fast because you don’t have to share the performance with anyone else. Unlike shared, dedicated datacenter proxies have no bandwidth limitations and have exceptionally high uptime.  

However, it’s important to note that there are times when shared IP addresses can be as fast as the dedicated ones. Mainly, it depends on what other users connected to the same server are doing; in other words, how intense their traffic is. That said, if you choose shared IP addresses and require high performance, make sure to choose a premium service with a large IP pool. 

Security. Dedicated proxies are also called private as they are not shared with anyone else, and are usually secured by protocols - HTTP, HTTPS or SOCKS5. By buying dedicated proxies from a reliable IP address provider, you can be sure that your personal information won’t be compromised and will stay encrypted. Also, since dedicated proxies are assigned only to one user, there’s little chance of bandwidth overload.

However, if you want to enjoy all the benefits of dedicated proxies fully, choosing the right IP address provider is a task that shouldn’t be taken lightly. You might find providers that offer free dedicated proxies; however, in essence, dedicated proxies can’t be free. Don’t trust this false advertising, and make sure that you’re buying only from legitimate businesses. 

Pricing. When it comes to the price tag of dedicated vs. shared proxies, dedicated proxies are not as cheap as shared ones. Since proxy providers are selling one IP address to just one user, that user has to cover the full cost of maintaining the dedicated proxies’ servers. Meanwhile, shared proxies are known to be the most cheap proxy solution when it comes to web scraping. 

Let's take a look at a concrete example and compare what amounts and values you'd get for $200 with Oxylabs' dedicated vs. shared IPs.

Bear in mind that it's just a specific example of US IPs against other countries, and the numbers vary from case to case. However, it's clear that the same $200 amount offers different features for each proxy type.

Target website type. Shared proxies are ideal for scraping niche websites that are not typically scraped by other people – such websites are less likely to use anti-bot measures. In other words, you won’t be impacted by other people using the same shared proxies and scraping totally different sites. 

Another scenario when shared proxies are recommended is when your target website doesn’t seem to resist being scraped and are less likely to be using heavy anti-bot measures; however, you still need proxies for anonymity and location spoofing.  

Final note. At the end of the day, both shared and dedicated IP addresses belong in the dedicated IP address category. Shared and dedicated IPs aren’t as different as, say, residential proxies and datacanter proxies would be. 

The main factors we went through – speed, security, etc. – more so help to evaluate the entire proxy and IP address market, especially, when it comes to the free ones with no proper IP reputation guarantees or ownership. At Oxylabs, you can safely choose either proxy type, without having to worry about your speed and security being compromised. 

Conclusion

Although dedicated IP addresses can seem like an obvious choice in most cases, we want to stress that it all depends on your needs. If you’re looking for cost-efficiency, most likely your choice will be shared IP addresses. If you’re not sure if dedicated proxies are the right choice for you or your business, drop us a line, and we’ll help you decide.

To learn more about different proxies, you can read our blog for such posts as ISP vs. residential proxies.